Choice of tree

lennarda

Hello,

Unfortunatly I had to fell a horse chestnut tree in my garden - as it was rotten. I have been asked to replant it with either a Birch, Rowen or White Beam tree. I have clay soil, live in England and the tree will be about 10m from my house. Any ideas what the most suitable tree would be?

Thank you,

Tony

Garry Brockley

hi lennard the White beam prefers a chalky or limestone soil it can grow to 20 meters ish a nice tree but probably not for your location but dont completely dismiss it.
the Rowan is a small tree that likes wet feet it can be messy with the fruit but is an elegant small tree not like your horse chestnut.
the Birch is a nice tree it would probably sit in the space nicely but you will have to do a bit of work on the surrounding clay soil as they like a more free draining media.
with all of the trees get them from a reputable scource and ensure they have an established central leader, they are healthy and have green leaves not yellowing (unless its fall) winter is a good time to replant, if you get it from a nursery protect it from harsh winds and hardfrosts unless you choose one that is kept out in the elements.
hope that helps

__________________