Quote:
Originally Posted by treeseer Mario, if the added soil is loose, is there really a great fear of smothering? I think not. Most urban trees are eroded due to the removal of their leaves, wind, water, and other factors, so it makes sense to replace soil to make up for what has been taken away. |
In lawn areas, not usual, but it still happens sometimes. No accident that the lawn starts at sidewalk height on the the downslope, and in 10 years is 2" above the sidewalk concrete

Good point.
But the erosion you mention if prevalent in a lot of areas of Portland.
Sure, replacement makes a lot of sense.